Taking a Knee: Good or Bad?
After the presidential election, the nation has gotten more divided on certain political issues. One political issue currently going on in the U.S. is the issue regarding an act of protest during the national anthem. Football players are taking a knee to protest race inequality, police brutality, and concerns about Trump’s administration. This has become prevalent throughout the entire U.S. and has led to debates in the SSFS community on whether or not this is the right way to protest.
One side is opposed to the idea of protesting in this movement as they believe it is disrespecting what the flag stands for and how soldiers sacrificed their lives for that national anthem. A student at SSFS who asked to remain anonymous said, “I can see why they do it, but in the process, they are also disrespecting the troops that fight to protect this country.” He believes that this movement should end as it is doing more harm than good. Although people in the group can, for the most part, understand where people are coming from when they choose to take a knee during the national anthem, they still think this is not a correct form of protest and should choose a better way to rebel. Even though it is directed towards Trump’s administration, it is also indirectly affecting people who have served in the military by making it seem like the protesters aren’t grateful for their service.
The other side is in agreement with taking a knee during the national anthem as a way of standing up the problems African Americans face. In order to evoke change, people need to be aware of the issues African Americans face. Steven Aldridge, a senior at SSFS, supports this movement. He says, “it’s a very visible and effective form of protest. Taking a knee has been a very effective way of starting a dialogue about police brutality and racial injustice in the United States.” When asked about whether this divided the country even more, he responded by saying, “Not really. The country is not more divided than it always has been. People felt uncomfortable voicing their differences because it wasn’t socially acceptable but the people who felt some way, always felt some way. We’re just finally at a point where we’ve accepted that we are a divided nation and we’re no longer avoiding the conflict that comes with division.”
This issue has had increased controversy over the last couple of weeks and people are still deciding whether or not they want to take a side. Both sides drive valid points for their arguments and this makes the issue on who is right more complicated. Time will eventually tell what comes out of this whole movement and who will be affected.
Hello everyone! My name is Jeremy and this is my second year on the school newspaper. I am in charge of editing articles that fall under the following...
Ryan Barnes • May 2, 2018 at 11:39 am
I think the players can do what they want. Not everyone supports the nation anthem because there are racist actions happening in America. Police harming inmocent people because of there race is a good reason to protest the anthem. I agree with the cause and I think it should continue
Quinn Bittinger-Esser • Nov 3, 2017 at 8:25 am
I understand why these players have chosen this way to protest but is it really the most affective way? Of course there are serious issues in this country involving racism and police brutality but why choose a form of protest that so many people find offensive? Personally, I want to help solve this problem in any means necessary but at the same time I think kneeling during the anthem is disrespectful. The flag and anthem embody so many things: our brave men and women, the police good and bad, our politicians, and every citizen of this great country. There are so many other ways that these players could solve these problems and I do not believe this to be the best way to bring attention to them.
Ben GG • Oct 31, 2017 at 9:25 pm
Racism has become so American that when you protest racism people think you’re protesting America. Nobody is getting hurt in these protests. It’s essentially the most pacifistic way of protest possible. You shouldn’t be obligated to stand for a nation that doesn’t protect you. The people upset about it are the ones not protecting the minorities, and the ones who say America’s not great. Apparently great only applies to their direct interest. Not only was the national anthem drawn to football games as fake support to drum up support for the Gulf War, it has no place at football. Why do sports have anything to do with country? This is an absurdity based around our ethnocentric beliefs that our countries are the prime division between us. Sports should be completely separate from politics, but as long as one side keeps it there, we will protest there.
Overall a very interesting article that does a good job summarizing both sides clearly, and logically explaining viewpoints.
Lucas Niepold • Oct 25, 2017 at 1:22 pm
I think that your point is very moving. I think that taking a knee when the flag Is raised for a reason of racial injustice and police brutality makes not a ton of sense. What I’m saying is that police brutality and racial injustice doesn’t totally connect to the flag and all the soldiers that fought for it.